Publish in this journal
Journal Information
Vol. 88. Num. 6.01 June 2018
Pages 299-356
Visits
223
Vol. 88. Num. 6.01 June 2018
Pages 299-356
Original Article
DOI: 10.1016/j.anpede.2017.06.004
Full text access
Influence of demographic changes on the number of visits to hospital emergency departments: 13 years’ experience
Influencia de los cambios demográficos en la frecuentación de urgencias hospitalarias: 13 años de experiencia
Visits
223
José Lorenzo Guerra Dieza,
Corresponding author
jguerra@humv.es

Corresponding author.
, Luis Gaite Pindadob, Cristina Álvarez Álvareza, María Teresa Leonardo Cabelloa, Lino Álvarez Grandac, María Jesús Cabero Pérezd
a Urgencias de Pediatría, Hospital Marqués de Valdecilla, Santander, Spain
b Unidad de Evaluación, Servicio de Psiquiatría, Hospital Marqués de Valdecilla, Santander, Spain
c Servicio de Pediatría, Hospital Marqués de Valdecilla, Santander, Spain
d Sección de Pediatría, Hospital Marqués de Valdecilla, Santander, Spain
This item has received
223
Visits
Article information
Abstract
Full Text
Bibliography
Download PDF
Statistics
Figures (3)
Show moreShow less
Tables (4)
Table 1. Changes in paediatric emergency department (PED) utilisation and the paediatric population in the 2001–2013 period.
Table 2. Annual changes in the number of paediatric emergency department (PED) visits in Cantabria (overall and by age group).
Table 3. Annual changes in the paediatric population of Cantabria (overall and by age group).
Table 4. Evolution by year of the number of emergency department visits per 10000 inhabitants.
Show moreShow less
Abstract
Objective

The aim of the present study is to describe the trend in volume and age-specific rates in visits to the paediatric emergency department of a university teaching hospital in Cantabria (Spain) from January 2001 to December 2013, and evaluate the influence of population growth on emergency department use.

Material and methods

A retrospective study was conducted to analyze all emergency department visits over a 13 year period. Simple and polynomial linear regressions were used to assess the relationship between population size and emergency department attendance rates across 2 age groups (0–2 and 3–14 years).

Results

From 2001 to 2013, attendance in the emergency department increased by 14.1%, whereas the paediatric population rose by 26.3%. Rates of presentation per head of population were greatest among those aged <3 years: 1.48 (95% CI 1.40 to 1.56) vs. 0.46 (95% CI 0.44 to 0.48) for the older age group (P<.01). A significant regression equation was found (F[1,11]=11.2, P<.05) with an R2=0.50, showing that population growth produces a continuous rise in the emergency department visits for those aged <3 years. However, ED presentations of patients aged 3–14 years fit a quadratic regression model (R2=0.48, F[2,10]=4.6, P<.05) so increases in population rise ED presentations until an inflection point, after which increases in population will decrease ED visits.

Conclusions

Those aged 0–2 years presented a steady increase in ED visits related to population growth, whereas children aged 3–14 years experienced a “saturation of the demand” and a reduction in ED presentations.

Keywords:
Emergency department
Use
Paediatric patients
Paediatric care
Resumen
Objetivo

Este estudio evalúa la influencia del crecimiento de la población en la utilización del Servicio de Urgencias Pediátricas de un hospital universitario de Cantabria (España) entre enero de 2001 y diciembre de 2013.

Material y métodos

Se realizó un estudio retrospectivo de todas las urgencias ocurridas durante 13 años. Se emplean modelos de regresión lineal simple y polinómica para analizar la relación entre la población y la frecuentación en 2 grupos de edad (0-2 y 3-14 años).

Resultados

De 2001 a 2013, las urgencias aumentaron un 14,1% y la población pediátrica un 26,3%. Las tasas de presentación por persona fueron mayores en los menores de 3 años, 1,48 (IC 95% 1,40 a 1,56) frente a 0,46 (IC 95% 0,44 a 0,48) (p<0,01). El modelo de regresión lineal simple muestra que el crecimiento de la población produce un aumento continuo de las urgencias en los menores de 3 años (R2=0,50, F[1,11]=11,2, p<0,05). En pacientes de 3 a 14 años la frecuentación se ajusta a un modelo de regresión cuadrática (R2=0,48, F[2,10]=4.6, p<05) y el incremento de la población aumenta las urgencias hasta alcanzar un punto de inflexión a partir del cual disminuyen.

Conclusiones

El grupo de edad de 0 a 2 años presentó un aumento constante en las urgencias relacionado con el crecimiento de la población, mientras que el grupo de 3 a 14 años experimentó una «saturación de la demanda» y una reducción de las visitas.

Palabras clave:
Urgencias
Utilización
Pacientes pediátricos
Frecuentación
Full Text
Introduction

Paediatric emergency departments are at the front line of health care systems and play an essential role in guaranteeing a quick and high-quality response to patients seeking care. In general, the number of individuals seeking health services has been increasing continuously through time, independently of variations in birth rates and/or population drains1 in the catchment areas of health facilities. This appears to be an all but universal phenomenon regardless of the health care setting under consideration.2–4

The increase in the demand for services usually exceeds the growth of health care resources and can become a problem, with a negative impact in both the quality of the provided care as well as patient safety. Adequate planning is essential to meet the health care needs of a population,5 and estimating the health care needs of a specific geographical area requires taking into account the characteristics of the paediatric population, including the total size of the population and its distribution by age groups. Although it is fair to assume that demand results from the interplay of multiple factors, we believe that the demographic profile of the population receiving services is a significant contributor. Accurate knowledge of relevant demographic characteristics may be very useful in deciding whether to establish additional after-hours urgent care service points, predicting the impact of seasonal diseases and planning the allocation of human resources to emergency services.

Although numerous studies have assessed the volume of emergency department use and the most prevalent health problems in different geographical areas,6–9 they rarely analyse the demographic characteristics of an area taking into account changes in the paediatric population. Consequently, we do not know with certainty whether population characteristics are directly associated with paediatric emergency department utilisation, especially in the long term.

The aim of this study was to determine the frequency of hospital paediatric emergency department utilisation in the region of Cantabria over a period of 13 years, analyse changes in the characteristics of the paediatric population through this period, and assess whether there is an association between the two.

Materials and methods

We conducted a retrospective ecological study using administrative records on the use of paediatric emergency services in the autonomous community of Cantabria between 2001 and 2013. We determined the annual number of visits to the emergency department based on information provided by the Intake and Clinical Documentation Department of the Hospital Universitario Marqués de Valdecilla. We collected and used these data in adherence to our hospital's regulations on epidemiology studies, aggregated data before the statistical analysis, and accessed none of the personal data contained in health records.

In order to guarantee that changes in the availability of paediatric health services did not influence emergency department utilisation, we selected a time period for analysis during which the structure and capacity of the paediatric emergency and paediatric primary care services network remained unchanged. In our study, we defined the paediatric population eligible for paediatric emergency care as the set of individuals aged 14 or fewer years, as this was the legal age limit in our region. We determined the size of the paediatric population based on data from the Instituto Cántabro de Estadística (Statistic Institute of Cantabria, www.icane.es), Population Section, population data and municipal census.

We performed a descriptive analysis, calculating the number of paediatric emergencies managed each year and the crude rate of emergency department use per 10000 inhabitants for the overall population and for the populations of children aged less than 3 years and children aged 3 or more years, assessing potential differences between them by means of the Student t test.

To assess the association between population size, age and emergency department utilisation, we used the Pearson correlation coefficient and simple linear or polynomial regression.10 We defined statistical significance for all tests as a P-value of less than 0.05, and we conducted the analysis with the software SPSS version 21 for Windows.

Results

Between 2001 and 2013 there were a total of 600001 paediatric emergency visits in Cantabria. Table 1 shows the main changes in emergency department utilisation and in the paediatric population. Table 2 shows the annual changes in the frequency of emergency department use and Table 3 the annual changes in the paediatric population. The mean emergency department utilisation rate was of 6968 visits per 10000 inhabitants (95% CI, 6585 to 7350) (Table 4). In the population aged less than 3 years, the mean rate was 14810 visits per 10000 inhabitants (95% CI, 13966 to 15664), and the mean rate in older children was 4692 visits per 10000 inhabitants (95% CI, 4448 to 4936) (P<.01). At the individual level, the mean number of visits was 1.48 visits per child (95% CI, 1.40 to 1.56) in children aged less than 3 years, and 0.46 (95% CI, 0.44 to 0.48) in older children, with a statistically significant difference between the two age groups (P<.01).

Table 1.

Changes in paediatric emergency department (PED) utilisation and the paediatric population in the 2001–2013 period.

2001  2013  DifferenceMean annual growth
n  n  n  95% CI 
Number of hospital-based PEDs  –  –  –  – 
Total PED visits  38843  44344  5501  14.1  0.9  −3.1 to 4.9 
Paediatric population  59510  75197  15687  26.3  1.9  1.1 to 2.7 
PED visits, age <3 years  17782  20006  2224  12.5  0.7  −3.6 to 5.0 
Paediatric population aged <3 years  11459  15828  4369  38.1  2.8  0.2 to 5.3 
PED visits, age 3–14 years  21061  24338  3277  15.5  1.3  −4.5 to 7.2 
Paediatric population aged 3–14 years  48051  59369  11318  23.5  1.9  0.9 to 2.9 
Table 2.

Annual changes in the number of paediatric emergency department (PED) visits in Cantabria (overall and by age group).

YearTotal PED visitsAnnual changePED visits, age <3 yearsAnnual changePED visits, age 3–14 yearsAnnual change
n  n  n 
2001  38843  –  –  17782  –  –  21061  –  – 
2002  39544  701  1.8  18547  765  4.1  20997  −64  −0.3 
2003  45835  6291  13.7  21353  2806  13.1  24482  3485  16.5 
2004  43063  −2772  −6.4  20777  −576  −2.8  22286  −2196  −10.4 
2005  45891  2828  6.2  22633  1856  8.2  23258  972  4.6 
2006  50442  4551  9.0  24245  1612  6.6  26197  2939  14.0 
2007  50360  −82  −0.2  24897  652  2.6  25463  −734  −3.5 
2008  48565  −1795  −3.7  23841  −1056  −4.4  24724  −739  −3.5 
2009  49982  1417  2.8  23312  −529  −2.3  26670  1946  9.2 
2010  48385  −1597  −3.3  24366  1054  4.3  24019  −2651  −12.6 
2011  49149  764  1.6  23277  −1089  −4.7  25872  1853  8.8 
2012  45598  −3551  −7.8  21013  −2264  −10.8  24585  −1287  −6.1 
2013  44344  −1254  −2.8  20006  −1007  −5.0  24338  −247  −1.2 
Table 3.

Annual changes in the paediatric population of Cantabria (overall and by age group).

YearPaediatric populationAnnual changePopulation aged <3 yearsAnnual changePopulation aged 3–14 yearsAnnual change
n  n  n 
2001  59510  –  –  11459  –  –  48051  –  – 
2002  59465  −45  −0.1  11993  534  4.7  47472  −579  −1.2 
2003  60669  1204  2.0  13076  1083  9.0  47593  121  0.3 
2004  61755  1086  1.8  13563  487  3.7  48192  599  1.2 
2005  62890  1135  1.8  14431  868  6.4  48459  267  0.6 
2006  64255  1365  2.2  15072  641  4.4  49183  724  1.5 
2007  65377  1122  1.7  15165  93  0.6  50212  1029  2.1 
2008  67647  2270  3.5  15693  528  3.5  51954  1742  3.6 
2009  70813  3166  4.7  16838  1145  7.3  53975  2021  4.2 
2010  72519  1706  2.4  17122  284  1.7  55397  1422  3.0 
2011  73571  1052  1.5  16920  −202  −1.2  56651  1254  2.6 
2012  74717  1146  1.6  16468  −452  −2.7  58249  1598  3.3 
2013  75197  480  0.6  15828  −640  −3.9  59369  1120  2.3 
Table 4.

Evolution by year of the number of emergency department visits per 10000 inhabitants.

Year  Number of visits—overall  Number of visits—population aged <3 years  Number of visits—population aged 3–14 years 
2001  6527  15518  4383 
2002  6650  15465  4423 
2003  7555  16330  5144 
2004  6973  15319  4624 
2005  7297  15684  4800 
2006  7850  16086  5326 
2007  7703  16417  5071 
2008  7179  15192  4759 
2009  7058  13845  4941 
2010  6672  14231  4336 
2011  6680  13757  4567 
2012  6103  12760  4221 
2013  5897  12640  4099 

When we compared the growth in the overall population and emergency department utilisation using the Pearson correlation coefficient, we did not find a statistically significant correlation between the two variables (r=0.48; 95% CI, −0.1 to 0.8; P<.05), and we also found no significant correlation for the subpopulation of children aged 3 or more years (r=0.5; 95% CI, −0.1 to 0.8; P<.05). However, when it came to children aged less than 3 years, the number of visits to the emergency department was significantly and positively correlated to the size of the population (r=0.71; 95% CI, 0.26 to 0.91; P<.01).

Using these data, we performed a simple linear regression analysis to assess whether population size could predict emergency department use. The results of simple linear regression showed that in children aged less than 3 years, population size explained 50% of the variance (R2=0.50; F[1,11]=11.2, P<.05) (Fig. 1).

Figure 1.
(0.13MB).

Scatterplot with best-fit line and 95% confidence interval of the size of the population aged less than 3 years versus the number of emergency department visits over a 13-year period.

When it came to the population of children aged 3 or more years, the association with emergency department use did not fit a linear model, but a quadratic model in which starting at some point, emergency department use decreased with increasing age (R2=0.48; F[2,10]=4.6; P<.05) (Fig. 2).

Figure 2.
(0.15MB).

Scatterplot with best-fit curve and 95% confidence interval of the size of the population aged 3 or more years versus the number of emergency department visits over a 13-year period.

For the overall paediatric population, the model that was the best fit for emergency department utilisation was also quadratic (R2=0.84; F[2,10]=27.2; P<.001) (Fig. 3).

Figure 3.
(0.15MB).

Scatterplot with best-fit curve and 95% confidence interval of the size of the overall paediatric populations versus the number of emergency department visits over a 13-year period.

Discussion

Our study shows that emergency department utilisation grew by 14.1% between 2001 and 2013. During this same period, the paediatric population grew by 26.3%. It is important to consider that during this period, the supply of hospital-based paediatric emergency services remained constant, as there was only one referral hospital with an emergency department in the entire autonomous community. There were also no changes in the structure of primary care paediatric services over this period, during which there was a constant number of after-hours urgent care clinics staffed by physicians specialised in family and community medicine. Both circumstances provided a unique opportunity to assess trends in health care demand when the health care supply remains constant and there are demographic changes, quantitative and qualitative, in the catchment population.

Unexpectedly, the increase in the paediatric population was not associated with a proportional overall increase in emergency department utilisation. It would be fair to expect that on analysing the association between population size and the number of emergency visits, a linear correlation would be found whereby population increases would be associated with demand increases. If we had happened to analyse only the period between 2001 and 2007, for instance, that is what our study would have found. However, by analysing a longer period of time, we found that when the total paediatric population eligible for paediatric emergency services exceeded 66000 individuals, emergency department utilisation started to decline, as can be seen in Fig. 3. Rather than through a linear model, this pattern can be better explained as a function of the population through polynomic regression with a quadratic model shaped like an inverted U. Due to the characteristics of our study, we were unable to determine the exact causes of this pattern, although it would be reasonable to assume that differences in morbidity between the years under study or seasonal epidemic diseases were probably not responsible for changes in emergency department utilisation over such a prolonged period. If we consider the accessibility of services in terms of time or cost, it does not seem to be a factor contributing to these changes in utilisation, as access to emergency care services in Spain is universal, and the services are available 24h 7 days a week. Thus, there must be other factors at play in this “saturation of demand” phenomenon.

The pattern of utilisation was different in children aged less than 3 years, with a clear linear correlation between population size and number of visits. This pattern has also been reported in previous studies on paediatric emergency department utilisation of similar characteristics.11,12 In addition, we also found another statistically significant difference in our study, as the utilisation rate in this age group was 1.48 visits per child (95% CI, 1.40 to 1.56), compared to 0.46 in older children (95% CI, 0.44 to 0.48). This difference is probably due to differences in actual morbidity, as infants and preschool-aged children are more susceptible to disease,12–15 and the most frequent reasons for seeking emergency care in this age group are fever and respiratory symptoms.7,12,13 We also need to take into account the reasons that lead parents to visit the emergency department, as the WHO defines an emergency as the sudden onset in any setting or situation of a problem of variable aetiology and severity perceived by the affected individual or the family as requiring immediate medical attention. Thus, the demand for urgent paediatric care is associated with the intrinsic severity of the symptoms presented by children but also with social and family-related factors, such as the anxiety generated in family members by symptoms manifested by a child, the compatibility of the work schedules of the parents or guardians with the opening hours of primary care services, or the perceived need for immediate attention.16 These are some of the factors that contribute to the more frequent use of emergency services by children aged less than 3 compared to older children or to individuals choosing to visit the emergency department as the first option for conditions that are usually not urgent,17 and they are probably involved in the pattern observed in our population.

In contrast, we found a decrease in demand in the population aged 3–14 years once the population grew to 56000 inhabitants. The most plausible explanation for the appearance of this “saturation of demand” is that from age 3 years onward, parents are less anxious about symptoms in their children and choose not to visit the emergency department or to wait longer before seeking care for minor health problems. Furthermore, the availability of after-hours urgent care clinics staffed by family physicians in areas that are far from the referral hospital may provide an appealing alternative to parents of older children that feel less anxious about their symptoms.

Some of the strengths of our study are that it is based on administrative data collected in the context of real-life practice over a period of 13 years, that it analysed every emergency department visit made in the period under study, and that there were no changes in the facilities that offered paediatric emergency care during that period. The considerable length of the period covered in our study allowed us to assess time trends in emergency department use in a health care ecosystem in which the only major change has been demographic. The probability that our findings result from selection bias or the presence of a seasonal factor is low. Some of the limitations of the study are its retrospective design and that we only had access to data routinely collected in our hospital, and were therefore unable to consider other variables when we fitted the statistical models that may have a relevant impact on emergency department use, such as the most frequent diagnoses or potential variations in wait times. Thus, we can only hypothesise about their potential contribution to parental demand for emergency care.

Last of all, we would like to mention that, to our knowledge, this is the first study that has detected a clear decrease in the demand for paediatric emergency services as the population increased over a prolonged period (13 years), as can be seen in Fig. 3. Based on our results, we conclude that population size does have an impact on paediatric emergency department utilisation, but that this impact varies depending on age. In children aged less than 3 years, the demand has grown continuously, with a direct correlation to population size. Conversely, in older children the increase in emergency department use is not sustained, as there is an inflection point once the population reaches a certain size after with utilisation plateaus or even decreases while the supply of services remains constant. While we do not believe that this phenomenon can be explained exclusively by demographic changes, our data allow us to state that increases in population size in isolation from other factors do not always entail a proportional increase in paediatric emergency department utilisation. This information should be taken into account in the planning and management of paediatric emergency care and the corresponding allocation of health care resources. Nevertheless, further studies with a prospective design should be conducted to better explain this complex situation.

Conflicts of interest

The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.

References
[1]
J.F.J. Elorza Arizmendi
Las urgencias pediátricas que acuden a centros hospitalarios
An Esp Pediatr, 49 (1998), pp. 650
[2]
S.M. Schneider,M.E. Gallery,R. Schafermeyer,F.L. Zwemer
Emergency department crowding: a point in time
Ann Emerg Med, 42 (2003), pp. 167-172
[3]
G.P. Young,M.B. Wagner,A.L. Kellermann,J. Ellis,D. Bouley
Ambulatory visits to hospital emergency departments. Patterns and reasons for use. 24 hours in the ED Study Group
JAMA, 276 (1996), pp. 460-465
[4]
L.F. McCaig,E.W. Nawar
National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2004 emergency department summary
Adv Data, (2006), pp. 1-29
[5]
R.H. Lucas,S.M. Sanford
An analysis of frequent users of emergency care at an urban university hospital
Ann Emerg Med, 32 (1998), pp. 563-568
[6]
J.K. Iribar Dieguez,R. Cancho Candela,S. Herrero Velázquez,A. Gómez Prieto,L. Gómez Fernández,J.M. Andrés de Llano
Estudio de la demanda de asistencia pediátrica en el servicio de urgencias de un hospital general de segundo nivel
Bol Pediatr, 44 (2004), pp. 20-25
[7]
S. Lapeña López de Armentia,S. Reguero Celada,M. García Rabanal,M. Gutiérrez Fernández,I. Abdallah,H. González Aparicio
Estudio epidemiológico de las urgencias pediátricas en un hospital general. Factores implicados en una demanda inadecuada
An Esp Pediatr, 44 (1996), pp. 121-125
[8]
M. García Fructuoso,A. Fernández López,J.J. García García,J. Ortega Rodríguez,C. Luaces Cubells,J. Pou Fernández
Demanda asistencial y perfil actual del usuario de un servicio de urgencias pediátrico de tercer nivel
Arch Pediatr, 50 (1998), pp. 1149-1150
[9]
G. Fernández Cano,G. Martín Carballo
Urgencias pediátricas atendidas en una consulta de atención primaria (II): estudio epidemiológico
Aten Primaria, 26 (2000), pp. 81-85
[10]
P. Armitage,G. Berry,J.N.S. Matthews
Statistical methods in medical research
Blackwell Science Ltd., (2002)
[11]
J.L. Muñoz García,J.M. Fandiño Orgeira,J.A. Díaz Peromingo
Demanda asistencial de urgencias pediátricas atendidas en un hospital comarcal
Aten Primaria, 40 (2008), pp. 297-301
[12]
S. Mintegi Raso,J. Benito Fernández,S. García González,A. Corrales Fernández,M.J. Bartolomé Albistegui,N. Trebolazabala Quirante
Demanda y asistencia en un servicio de urgencias hospitalario
An Pediatr (Barc), 61 (2004), pp. 156-161
[13]
D. Oterino de la Fuente,S. Peiró Moreno
Utilización de los servicios de urgencias hospitalarios por ninos menores de dos años
An Pediatr (Barc), 58 (2003), pp. 23-28
[14]
A. Sacchetti,T. Warden,M.E. Moakes,V. Moyer
Can sick children tell time? Emergency department presentation patterns of critically ill children
Acad Emerg Med, 6 (1999), pp. 906-910
[15]
K. Armon,T. Stephenson,V. Gabriel,R. MacFaul,P. Eccleston,U. Werneke
Determining the common medical presenting problems to an accident and emergency department
Arch Dis Child, 84 (2001), pp. 390-392
[16]
L.I. Sansa Pérez,T. Orús Escola,S. Juncosa Font,M. Barredo Hernández,J. Travería Casanova
Frecuentación a los servicios de urgencias hospitalarios: motivaciones y características de las urgencias pediátricas
An Esp Pediatr, 44 (1996), pp. 97-104
[17]
A. Rivas García,G. Manrique Martín,L. Butragueño Laiseca,S. Mesa García,A. Campos Segura,V. Fernández Iglesia
Hiperfrecuentadores en urgencias. ¿Quiénes son? ¿Por qué consultan?
An Pediatr (Barc), 86 (2017), pp. 67-75

Please cite this article as: Guerra Diez JL, Gaite Pindado L, Álvarez Álvarez C, Leonardo Cabello MT, Álvarez Granda L, Cabero Pérez MJ. Influencia de los cambios demográficos en la frecuentación de urgencias hospitalarias: 13 años de experiencia. An Pediatr (Barc). 2018;88:322–328.

Copyright © 2017. Asociación Española de Pediatría
Idiomas
Anales de Pediatría (English Edition)

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Article options
Tools
es en
Política de cookies Cookies policy
Utilizamos cookies propias y de terceros para mejorar nuestros servicios y mostrarle publicidad relacionada con sus preferencias mediante el análisis de sus hábitos de navegación. Si continua navegando, consideramos que acepta su uso. Puede cambiar la configuración u obtener más información aquí. To improve our services and products, we use "cookies" (own or third parties authorized) to show advertising related to client preferences through the analyses of navigation customer behavior. Continuing navigation will be considered as acceptance of this use. You can change the settings or obtain more information by clicking here.
es en

¿Es usted profesional sanitario apto para prescribir o dispensar medicamentos?

Are you a health professional able to prescribe or dispense drugs?